Five Announcers Who Should Replace Kirk Herbstreit in Future College Football Video Games

June 4, 2026 - 13:12

The news that Kirk Herbstreit, the former Ohio State quarterback and longtime ESPN analyst, is reportedly stepping away from his role in the "College Football" video game series has fans wondering who might fill those big shoes. Herbstreit's voice has been a staple of the franchise for years, alongside Chris Fowler, and his departure leaves a noticeable gap in the broadcast booth. Here are five announcers who could bring fresh energy to the virtual gridiron.

First, Joel Klatt, Fox's lead college football analyst, has the perfect mix of sharp analysis and genuine enthusiasm. He already calls big games and understands the modern game's nuances. Second, Greg McElroy, a former Alabama quarterback and current ESPN commentator, offers a player's perspective and a smooth delivery. Third, Desmond Howard, the Heisman winner and "College GameDay" fixture, brings star power and a playful rivalry dynamic. Fourth, Pat McAfee, the energetic former punter, could inject a chaotic, entertaining style that younger fans would love. Finally, Brock Huard, a seasoned analyst for Fox, provides a calm, technical breakdown that balances out the excitement.

Each of these voices brings something different, from Klatt's credibility to McAfee's unpredictability. The next game needs an announcer who can capture the pageantry and passion of college football without trying to copy Herbstreit's exact style. Whoever gets the call will have a tough act to follow, but the booth is wide open for a new era.